There are a lot of those, aren't there! When I was teaching in a publc school, a student came to my class shortly before the first bell. She had been crying.
"My cat died," she wailed. I commiserated with her and got a bit teary myself in sympathy. Finally she asked the question that brought her to my room. "When I said it was in heaven, my dad laughed at me and said animals just become dirt when they die. Don't they go to heaven, like us?"
At the time, I was involved in a very fundamentalist prayer group within my larger church community. I knew that the church maintained the position that animals did not possess an immortal soul and did, in fact, simply return to earth at death. I knew the young girl wanted to hear anything but that, but I hesitated, not wishing to lie.
Sudenly I remember my second grade teacher, a dear nun, faced with the same question in a room filled with pet-loving seven-year-olds. She reminded us of our catechism: What is heaven but a place where we are with God in a state of perfect happiness. She told us how deeply God loved us, and that He would never deprive us of anything to make our joy complete in heaven, and if when we got there we wanted our pets, of course God would see to it that our pets were there. We were satisfied, as of course we would want our dear pets with us again. In later years, we were taught the church's bitter truth, but for the moment, we second graders were comforted and happy.
I told my student the same thing, and like me so many years before, she was comforted and happy.
She'd no sooner left the room than I was filled with doubt about my response. Visions of millstones hung around my neck filled me with regret. Had I led one of God's own astray? I quickly prayed for guidance, resolving to myself that I would retract my answer if that was the guidance I received. But I received no guidance as the students came, talking and laughing, into my classroom.
It was library day, so after homeroom I hurried to meet my classes there. I was glad I didn't have to teach, as my heart was so troubled by the morning's events.
After the librarian's lesson, the students wandered the stacks, choosing the books they wanted to check out for their monthly book report. One of their favorite tricks was to select ad book and, rather than remove it from the shelf, pull the top edge down so that the book protruded into the aisle to catch the unwary browser as he passed.
I wandered the aisles, too, pushing the books back into place as I monitored my class. Walking the library that morning, troubled as I was, I unthinkingly removed one book from the shelf, a large slender volume. I idly looked at it; it was an old volume, with no title visible on spine or front cover. I moved to return it to the shelf as usual but pulled it back out instead. I had a sudden curiosity as to the book's title. I opened the cover, intent on discovering the title of this particular book even as I recognized the triviality and foolishness of my desire. I persisted, though, and turned the beginning pages - and had one of those gasping moments when suddenly everything around you fades away.
The book whose title I'd felt such urgency to discover was The Cat who Went to Heaven, by Elizabeth Coatsworth.
I stared at the title page, and was surrounded by the deepest peace I've ever known. I had received the guidance I sought, and my heart was untroubled and light once more.
The Roman Catholic church hierarchy would disagree with me, I am sure, but I believe that sometimes our best guidance comes not from a dogmatic authority figure but from Loving Creator Godself, directly to us. And when that guidance comes, I believe that we can trust it.